Fake
Tan Photoprotects, but Not a Lot
Having
a tan may be so attractive to some people that they are beyond the
reach of health educators. An available alternative is the fake tan
induced by dihydroxyacetone (DHA). In recent years, improved
application techniques have produced less streaky, more acceptable
results. Researchers in Denmark investigated whether the pseudo tan
produced by DHA photoprotects skin from burning.
They
compared the minimal erythema dose values of treated and untreated
skin in 20 healthy volunteers. One of two concentrations of DHA
cream (5% or 20%) was applied to the upper back and forearm of
participants once or three times in the amount of 2 mg/cm2.
Phototesting with a solar simulator source was performed 22 to 26
hours after the last application, and the SPF of various application
variables was computed.
On
the back, DHA provided a SPF of 1.3 to 2.2, depending on
concentration and number of applications. The SPF values for forearm
skin were approximately twice those seen on the back (4.3 after
three applications of 20% cream).
COMMENT:
New application methods, such as spray-on devices, have improved the
cosmetic appearance of DHA-darkened skin. Toxicologists tell us that
DHA staining of the stratum corneum is relatively safe. It certainly
produces a tan color acceptable to many users, but the SPF data
presented in this study support a message that users need to hear:
Despite the tanned appearance it produces, DHA confers only modest
photoprotection.
James
Ferguson, MD
Faurscbou
A et al. Sun protection effect of I dibydroxyacetone. Arch Dermato1
2004 Jul; 140:886-7.